For too long, Black mothers have carried the weight of an unequal healthcare system—one that often dismisses our pain, ignores our needs, and fails to protect us during one of life’s most sacred transitions: birth.
But now, a new tool is emerging that could change the way we give birth in America—one hospital at a time.
Welcome to the era of Maternity Care Report Cards—a bold step toward accountability, equity, and transparency in maternal health.
✨ What Are Maternity Care Report Cards?
Maternity Care Report Cards are structured evaluations that rate hospitals and states on the quality and equity of their maternal care. Think of them as a grading system for birth facilities—where patients, advocates, and lawmakers can see exactly how a hospital or region is doing when it comes to protecting mothers and babies.
These report cards are still new, but they’re growing fast—and they’re already proving to be a powerful tool in the fight against Black maternal health disparities.
📊 What Do They Measure?
Each report card varies depending on the organization or state, but many include the following:
- Maternal mortality and morbidity rates
- C-section rates and birth complications
- Access to doulas and midwives
- Racial disparities in birth outcomes
- Hospital diversity, equity, and inclusion practices
- Patient safety protocols
- Mental health screenings and support
- Patient satisfaction and respectful care metrics
Some report cards go deeper, examining hospital policies around allowing support people (like doulas), how staff are trained in cultural humility, or whether translation services are available for non-English-speaking mothers.
These aren’t just numbers—they’re stories of survival, neglect, healing, and transformation.
🗺️ Where Are They Being Used?
Several states and national organizations are stepping up with their own versions of maternity care scorecards. Here are a few making headlines:
🟪 Connecticut
In 2025, Connecticut introduced a groundbreaking bill that would require all hospitals to publish annual Maternity Care Report Cards. The bill includes a focus on racial equity, staff diversity, and patient safety, and aims to empower mothers with the information they need to make the best decisions about where to give birth. It also removes barriers to doula access and proposes a Perinatal Mental Health Task Force to address emotional care after childbirth.
🟨 New Jersey
New Jersey was one of the first states to launch hospital-level maternal report cards through its Nurture NJ initiative in 2022. These scorecards highlight complication rates, racial disparities, and support services across birth facilities, helping parents choose safer options and pushing hospitals to improve care.
🌐 Nationally
- The Policy Center for Maternal Mental Health releases annual State Mental Health Report Cards, which assess perinatal mental health support systems across all 50 states. In 2025, the U.S. received a national average grade of C‑, with 19 states earning a D or F.
- The Leapfrog Group issues scorecards on childbirth practices, including unnecessary C-sections and hospital safety protocols.
- March of Dimes publishes annual state-level reports on preterm birth rates, infant health, and health policy gaps—highlighting where states are falling short and where they’re making progress.
🖤 Why This Matters for Black Mothers
Black women in America are nearly three times more likely to die from pregnancy-related causes than white women. The reasons? Structural racism, bias in healthcare, lack of access to culturally competent care, and systems that fail to listen to Black mothers when they speak up.
Maternity Care Report Cards shine a bright light on the problem and help us move toward real solutions:
- They amplify accountability in hospitals.
- They inform mothers and families about where they’ll be treated with respect.
- They support advocacy efforts that are already led by Black women and birth workers.
- And most importantly—they put data in the hands of the community, where it belongs.
These scorecards are not a cure-all—but they are a step in the right direction. A tool for justice. A way to honor Black motherhood by demanding better.
✊🏾 What Comes Next?
As more states consider implementing report cards, and as more mothers demand transparency and safety, this movement will grow. But change also starts with awareness.
So share this post.
Talk about this with your sisters, daughters, doulas, and friends.
Ask your hospital what they’re doing to improve maternal care.
And when the time comes—demand the grade.
Because when we hold the system accountable, we protect our legacy.
Sources:
- CT Insider
- Policy Center for Maternal Mental Health
- Leapfrog Maternity Care Reports
- March of Dimes 2024 Report Cards
Lakischa Smith, Creator of Moms of Color